Charmed With Prue or Paige

do you think Charmed would have been better if Shannen stayed and Rose never came, or you happy Rose came in and took over, what would have charmed been like 5 extra seasons with Miss Doherty ?

I would have been happy ethier way. I like them both.

I hate questions like these. It's like asking me what arm I wanna chop off..

Well...since you asked Mz. Ashley,

I think each actress contributed significantly to the show in their own way....that's the textbook answer (smile). But personally, I'm not looking at whether it was Shannen or Rose....I kinda preferred Paige being introduced in the show. Reason is, "Prue" dominated the Halliwell sisters in S1-3. When Paige came, "Piper" became the older sister and thus we got to see more of Piper's capabilities, strength and powers....plus her relationship with Leo intensified and that was a good thing!

Natalie wrote:

Well...since you asked Mz. Ashley,

I think each actress contributed significantly to the show in their own way....that's the textbook answer (smile). But personally, I'm not looking at whether it was Shannen or Rose....I kinda preferred Paige being introduced in the show. Reason is, "Prue" dominated the Halliwell sisters in S1-3. When Paige came, "Piper" became the older sister and thus we got to see more of Piper's capabilities, strength and powers....plus her relationship with Leo intensified and that was a good thing!

yeah i do believe Piper & Leo made the show, but with that being said. loosing Prue was a big effect on them, but at the same time it was interesting to see Rose come in because if we just had those 3 throughout the whole series it would have gotten abit boring, im probably the biggest Shannen fan you'll ever come across but yeah i agree with you there. plus Shannen apparently didn't like the show and Alyssa so why stay on a show if you hate it right?

Ashley101 wrote:

Natalie wrote:

Well...since you asked Mz. Ashley,

I think each actress contributed significantly to the show in their own way....that's the textbook answer (smile). But personally, I'm not looking at whether it was Shannen or Rose....I kinda preferred Paige being introduced in the show. Reason is, "Prue" dominated the Halliwell sisters in S1-3. When Paige came, "Piper" became the older sister and thus we got to see more of Piper's capabilities, strength and powers....plus her relationship with Leo intensified and that was a good thing!

yeah i do believe Piper & Leo made the show, but with that being said. loosing Prue was a big effect on them, but at the same time it was interesting to see Rose come in because if we just had those 3 throughout the whole series it would have gotten abit boring, im probably the biggest Shannen fan you'll ever come across but yeah i agree with you there. plus Shannen apparently didn't like the show and Alyssa so why stay on a show if you hate it right?

Well I think its a fun question & I agree with U guys.

Come to think of it...it would've been very interesting if Shannen stayed for the rest of the seasons...She's an amazing actress & an awesome person...she's 2nd on my fav list next to Holly...so I think it'd have been rather cool & interesting if she stayed. Of course Rose was great she definitely brought a new dynamic to the show...So in my opinion it would've been fun either ways...I love them both!

U know what I would've really loved...if Shannen stayed for the rest of the seasons & then if Rose came in & somehow created a new Power of 4 thing...that would've been really awesome...I would've loved to see all of them together...it definitely would've been really fun & interesting!

Hmmm...all 4 of them...yeah, I could see that! They would have been dynamic as a group.

Natalie wrote:

Hmmm...all 4 of them...yeah, I could see that! They would have been dynamic as a group.

yeah it would be awesome, who do you's think is the strongest? i think it was Prue but with Piper getting the blow up power its hard to compare .

Ashley101 wrote:

Natalie wrote:

Hmmm...all 4 of them...yeah, I could see that! They would have been dynamic as a group.

yeah it would be awesome, who do you's think is the strongest? i think it was Prue but with Piper getting the blow up power its hard to compare .

Well I think Prue was the strongest both physically(cuz of the telekinesis & astral projection power) & mentally(cuz she was the eldest & therefore had more sense of duties & responsibilities on her shoulders). But after she was gone Piper had to take the lead bearing the pain of loosing her elder sister & discovering that she has another baby sister which then made her the strongest out of the 3 both mentally & physically. So for me they both were strongest in their own way & time.

with Paige....I love Paige

PAIGE

Hey CharmedP!!!

Nice to meet ya!

Glad to see youve joined our lil BK family. I'm one of the original members of the BK Board. Hope I get to chat with you. If you follow twitter, you can also find me there @NatalyinAK

#BrianKrauseisDaMan!!